Newhouse
1/36
$1,710/mo
$260,0003bd·1ba·1,240sf
5 James Street, Middletown, PA 17057
Listing Courtesy of Coldwell Banker Realty
Homes for Sale in Middletown, PA
34 active listings · 1,681 sold since 2020
34
For Sale
$210K
Median Sale Price
7
Median Days on Market
100.1%
Sold-to-List
$133
Price / Sq Ft
Newest homes for sale in Middletown, PA
See all 34 on the mapMiddletown, PA home price trend
| Year | Median Sale Price | Homes Sold |
|---|---|---|
| 2026 | $260K | 131 |
| 2025 | $242K | 250 |
| 2024 | $235K | 281 |
| 2023 | $220K | 226 |
| 2022 | $198K | 261 |
| 2021 | $175K | 277 |
| 2020 | $155K | 255 |
At the current trend, the median is modeled to reach about $282K in 2027 (estimate).
Cost to buy in Middletown, PA
At today's ~6.63% 30-year rate, the median $210K home in Middletown, PA runs about $1,356/mo with 20% down (principal & interest plus estimated taxes and insurance).
Estimate only — not a loan offer. Actual rate and payment depend on your profile.
Top agents in Middletown, PA
Most active agents by closed sales here over the past 18 months.
- Don BeachyA' La Carte Real Estate Svcs19 sales
- Tim B. ClouserRE/MAX Realty Select12 sales
- Joy DanielsJoy Daniels Real Estate Group, Ltd9 sales
- Don BeachyA' La Carte Realty Services LLC9 sales
- Serena RiedelHoward Hanna Real Estate Services - Lancaster7 sales
Get new-listing alerts for Middletown, PA
Turn on instant alerts and we'll email you the moment a new home is listed in Middletown, PA.
Middletown, PA real estate FAQ
How many homes are for sale in Middletown, PA?
There are 34 homes currently for sale in Middletown, PA.
How much do homes sell for in Middletown, PA?
The median sale price in Middletown, PA is $210K, based on 1,681 sales since 2020 (ranging from $55K to $461K).
How fast do homes sell in Middletown, PA?
Homes in Middletown, PA typically go under contract in about 7 days on market (median).
Do homes in Middletown, PA sell above asking?
Over the past 12 months, homes in Middletown, PA sold for an average of 100.1% of list price — at or above asking.
What is the price per square foot in Middletown, PA?
Homes in Middletown, PA have sold for a median of $133 per square foot since 2020.
Is the Middletown, PA housing market heating up or cooling down?
The median sale price in Middletown, PA has risen from $155K in 2020 to $260K in 2026. At the current trend, the median is on track for roughly $282K in 2027 (modeled estimate).
Who are the top real estate agents in Middletown, PA?
The most active agents in Middletown, PA over the past 18 months are: Don Beachy (A' La Carte Real Estate Svcs) — 19 sales; Tim B. Clouser (RE/MAX Realty Select) — 12 sales; Joy Daniels (Joy Daniels Real Estate Group, Ltd) — 9 sales.
Neighborhoods & Subdivisions in Middletown, PA
- BROOKSIDE(1)
- Cameron Woods
- Dauphin County(1)
- Edgewater
- Georgetown
- Greenwood Hills(1)
- Harborton Place(2)
- Lisa Lake Mbh Park(4)
- Little Hollywood
- LONDONDERRY TOWNSHIP(1)
- Lower Swatara Township(1)
- Middletown Borough(2)
- Middletown(1)
- Midtown Historic District(1)
- Oak Hills(1)
- Old Reliance Farms(1)
- Old Reliance
- Pine Manor Mhp(2)
- Rosedale
- Royalton(1)
- Shopes Garden(3)
- Swatara Shores(1)
- Twelve Oaks
- Woodland Hills(5)
- Woodridge
