Newhouse
1/11
$3,501/mo
$532,4904bd·3ba·2,611sf
42 Bennington Way, Carlisle, PA 17013
Listing Courtesy of D.R. Horton Realty of Pennsylvania
Homes for Sale in Bennington, Carlisle, PA
7 active listings · 47 sold since 2020
7
For Sale
$406K
Median Sale Price
1
Median Days on Market
98.5%
Sold-to-List
$200
Price / Sq Ft
Newest homes for sale in Bennington, Carlisle, PA
See all 7 on the mapBennington, Carlisle, PA home price trend
| Year | Median Sale Price | Homes Sold |
|---|---|---|
| 2026 | $375K | 3 |
| 2025 | $434K | 6 |
| 2024 | $445K | 11 |
| 2023 | $445K | 5 |
| 2022 | $384K | 22 |
At the current trend, the median is modeled to reach about $408K in 2027 (estimate).
Cost to buy in Bennington, Carlisle, PA
At today's ~6.63% 30-year rate, the median $406K home in Bennington, Carlisle, PA runs about $2,619/mo with 20% down (principal & interest plus estimated taxes and insurance).
Estimate only — not a loan offer. Actual rate and payment depend on your profile.
Top agents in Bennington, Carlisle, PA
Most active agents by closed sales here over the past 18 months.
- Cj LongeneckerBerkshire Hathaway HomeServices Homesale Realty4 sales
- Laura M D'imperioBuilder Realty, LLC2 sales
- Laura M D'imperioCarper Realty, LLC2 sales
- Khadga Bahadur MagarPrime Realty Services1 sale
Get new-listing alerts for Bennington, Carlisle, PA
Turn on instant alerts and we'll email you the moment a new home is listed in Bennington, Carlisle, PA.
Bennington, Carlisle, PA real estate FAQ
How many homes are for sale in Bennington, Carlisle, PA?
There are 7 homes currently for sale in Bennington, Carlisle, PA.
How much do homes sell for in Bennington, Carlisle, PA?
The median sale price in Bennington, Carlisle, PA is $406K, based on 47 sales since 2020 (ranging from $355K to $486K).
How fast do homes sell in Bennington, Carlisle, PA?
Homes in Bennington, Carlisle, PA typically go under contract in about 1 day on market (median).
Do homes in Bennington, Carlisle, PA sell above asking?
Over the past 12 months, homes in Bennington, Carlisle, PA sold for an average of 98.5% of list price — below asking.
What is the price per square foot in Bennington, Carlisle, PA?
Homes in Bennington, Carlisle, PA have sold for a median of $200 per square foot since 2020.
Is the Bennington, Carlisle, PA housing market heating up or cooling down?
The median sale price in Bennington, Carlisle, PA has fallen from $384K in 2022 to $375K in 2026. At the current trend, the median is on track for roughly $408K in 2027 (modeled estimate).
Who are the top real estate agents in Bennington, Carlisle, PA?
The most active agents in Bennington, Carlisle, PA over the past 18 months are: Cj Longenecker (Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Homesale Realty) — 4 sales; Laura M D'imperio (Builder Realty, LLC) — 2 sales; Laura M D'imperio (Carper Realty, LLC) — 2 sales.
